The Crime of Modern Technology
Posted by Katharine Swan on July 28th, 2005In a bit of a break from the usual, I have more than just music in mind tonight. Lately I’ve been seeing on DVDs a lot of commercials that try to discourage downloading and burning movies by pointing out that it is a crime. I haven’t seen so much effort put into preventing this kind of “theft†for quite a while, if ever; CDs and VHS have always had the silent warning on the case and at the beginning of movies, but never with this attempt to guilt-trip young people. It makes me think, though – is it really a crime to copy these things? There are the normal arguments – that the artist or producer or whatever is not paid for the illegal copy, etc. And as a writer, I think about my own copyright concerns. My concerns, however, have more to do with the fear of my work being “stolen†– meaning not being attributed to me – rather than it being “stolen†– meaning not getting my pennies. Realistically, though, I’ve never written anything that didn’t earn a base pay, so perhaps it’s not the best comparison.
What I do know is that as our technology improves, information – of all kinds – gets easier and easier to “steal.†Perhaps the problem isn’t the “theft†anymore – perhaps the problem is our tendency as a society to cling to outdated notions. Back when putting something in print was the only way to get it read, the expense of doing so probably made copyright issues more serious. However, we are now trying to regulate information that is published instantly and world-wide – and for free. Is this really feasible? I think the laws will eventually be forced to change with the times, but until that happens we should continue to respect others’ rights, just as we would wish ours to be respected.
Recent Comments